Reply to comment
On the team (and probably in the photograph):
James Harris, Ben Dawson, Sebastian Raffa - captain, Robert M. H. Erickson, Traynor Halftown, William Thayer, Jack Love, Carmelo Basile, John Price, Ray Benbenek.
The names of the rest of the player are unknown. Perhaps you might recognize some of them.
Photo from the 1937 Red & Green Yearbook of Jamestown High School