Reply to comment
On the team - and probably in the photograph: S. M. Veach - Pitcher, R. E. Thorn - First Base, Fred Leroy Marshall - Catcher, W. R Wallace - Third Base, R. N. Penman - Pitcher, L. V. Knapp - Pitcher, O. H. Heckathorne - Middle Field, D. Kelly - Shortstop, L D. Shaw - Left Field, E. M. Schaffer - Right Field, P. E. Hill, Second Base. The manager was E. J. Peyton (probably the man in the suit).
The Coach was H. W. Harmon (not in photograph).
Photo from the 1917 Ouija Yearbook of Grove City College